Remembering Shay Litvak Our Co-Founder and CTO

November 1979 - September 2023

How to Compare Payroll Service Providers: A Practical Checklist

Hourly graphic: "Comparing payroll providers?" beside a checklist of six areas to score, from payroll accuracy to pricing transparency.Hourly graphic: "Comparing payroll providers?" beside a checklist of six areas to score, from payroll accuracy to pricing transparency.
7
min read
November 16, 2026

A clear, actionable checklist to evaluate payroll vendors on accuracy, compliance, integrations and total cost, so you can run payroll faster and keep Workers' Compensation costs predictable.

Request a demo

New to outsourcing payroll? Start with what a payroll provider does and whether one is worth it.

What should you look for in a payroll provider?

Look for six things: accurate, fast payroll runs; complete tax filing; Workers' Compensation that's tied to real payroll; integrations with your time tracking and accounting; responsive support; and transparent pricing. Score each vendor 1–5 in every category, then compare totals.

Each category protects you from a specific risk. Accuracy matters because the Fair Labor Standards Act requires employers to keep complete and accurate records of hours worked, pay rates and deductions, and to hold payroll records for at least three years. Tax filing matters because federal employment taxes must be deposited electronically on a monthly or semiweekly schedule. Ask every vendor how you can verify that deposits were made, and register for your own EFTPS account so you can check payment history yourself. Workers' Compensation, integrations, support and pricing are where vendors differ most, so the sections below show what to ask in each area.

How to use this checklist

Choosing a payroll provider affects monthly cash flow, audit risk and insurance premiums, so score every vendor on the same criteria. Prioritize items that save you time and reduce year-end surprises. A provider that links payroll, time tracking and Workers' Compensation cuts manual reconciliation and the gap between estimated and actual premiums.

Operational essentials: run payroll quickly and accurately

Why it matters: faster, reversible payroll runs reduce correction time and accounting overhead, and packaging payroll with time tracking removes duplicate data entry. For example, Hourly includes unlimited payroll runs, direct deposit and automated tax payments and filing.

Compliance and tax filing: reduce audit risk

Why it matters: incomplete filing support creates late penalties and surprise liabilities. The IRS notes that the employer is ultimately responsible for depositing and paying federal tax liabilities, even when a third party makes the deposits. Get each vendor's filing scope in writing.

Workers' Compensation integration: link premiums to real payroll

Why it matters: Pay-as-you-go billing avoids large up-front estimates and shrinks the gap between estimated and actual premium at audit. For example, Hourly's Pay-as-you-go Workers' Compensation calculates premiums each pay period from actual payroll and sends payments directly to the carrier.

A Workers' Compensation policy starts with an estimate, and the final premium audit is based on actual payroll, operations and job classifications for the expired coverage period. If your real payroll runs higher than the estimate, you owe the difference; if it runs lower, you may get money back. Premium is also driven by classification: each type of work carries a code and a rate per $100 of payroll, and NCCI's Class Look-Up tool lets you check the codes and rate history that apply to your crews. Pay-as-you-go programs can help because they let employers pay premiums based on actual payroll figures rather than estimates. They don't replace your policy, though, and they don't make coverage cheaper. You still need coverage that meets your state's requirements, and for private employers the U.S. Department of Labor notes that Workers' Compensation is overseen at the state level. Ask each vendor which carriers it supports, how it assigns class codes to each employee, and what reports it provides at audit time.

Integrations and data flow: avoid manual reconciliation

Why it matters: separate systems mean manual imports and more errors. One source of truth for hours, wages and premiums shortens month-end close. Check each vendor's help center for setup guides; Hourly's payroll help center includes a QuickBooks sync guide.

Service model and SLAs: who helps when payroll breaks

Why it matters: the vendor's support model decides how fast you recover from a mis-run or an agency notice. Ask for a named contact through your first three payroll cycles.

Slow support costs money. The IRS charges a Failure to Deposit Penalty that starts at 2% of the unpaid deposit and rises to 10% once a deposit is more than 15 days late, so a missed deposit that sits for a week costs more than one fixed the next day. Agency notices also come with response instructions, and the IRS says you should respond as directed in the notice, which means you need your vendor's records and help quickly. If you authorize a provider as a reporting agent on Form 8655, you can also have the IRS send the provider duplicate copies of notices about the returns and deposits it handles. In your demo, get support hours and urgent response times in writing.

Pricing transparency: compare total cost of ownership

Why it matters: low headline pricing can hide add-ons. Build a 12-month cost model for each finalist. Our payroll cost breakdown shows how.

References, case studies and implementation timeline

Ask each vendor for a case study from a similar business and a two-month cutover plan. Check third-party ratings and customer stories to confirm claims about time saved or premium changes. As of November 2026, business owners rate Hourly 4.8/5 on Capterra, Google and G2.

Quick comparison scorecard

CategoryScore (1–5)
Payroll accuracy and speed/5
Tax and compliance coverage/5
Workers' Compensation integration/5
Integrations (time, accounting)/5
Support and SLAs/5
Pricing transparency and total cost/5
Total/30

Use the total to rank vendors and decide which demos to book first. Running a formal selection? Use our payroll RFP and evaluation guide.

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for when comparing payroll providers?

Compare six areas: payroll accuracy and speed, tax filing coverage, Workers' Compensation integration, integrations with time tracking and accounting, support, and total cost. Score each 1–5 so vendors are judged the same way.

How do I score payroll vendors fairly?

Use the same scorecard for every vendor, score from written answers and a live demo, and break ties on compliance and pricing transparency.

Should payroll and Workers' Compensation be in the same system?

It helps. When premiums are calculated from actual payroll each pay period, you avoid large up-front deposits and reduce the gap between estimated and actual premium at audit.

What payroll fees should I ask about?

Ask about setup, per-employee fees and how an employee is counted, off-cycle runs, garnishments, year-end forms, faster deposit options and contract cancellation terms.

How long does it take to switch payroll providers?

Plan for a cutover of about two months, with a named contact through the first three payroll cycles. Ask each vendor for a milestone-based plan.

The takeaway

Use this checklist to compare vendors on the operational and compliance criteria that drive payroll accuracy and predictable insurance costs. Favor vendors that combine payroll, time tracking and Pay-as-you-go Workers' Compensation, because connected data means fewer audit surprises and less bookkeeping.

Next step

Ready to see it live? Request a demo and ask for a cutover plan and a 12-month cost estimate for your crew. You can also compare Hourly's plans.

Disclaimer: This blog post is provided for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, accounting, insurance or financial advice. Payroll, employment tax and Workers' Compensation requirements vary by state, industry and individual circumstances, and laws and regulations change. Before making decisions about payroll providers, tax filings, insurance coverage or compliance, consult a qualified tax professional, accountant, attorney, insurance advisor or other financial professional who can advise on your specific situation. References to third-party sources and websites are provided for convenience and do not imply endorsement, and Hourly is not responsible for their content.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.